top of page

Training That Transfers: Training Isn't Learning

Nov 9
6 min read
Aquatic Soft Skills

Why a successful in-service doesn't always mean successful learning


Think about the last in-service training you conducted. You had an agenda, activities planned, and maybe a few creative ways to get staff engaged. People participated, answered questions, practiced skills, and hopefully left feeling their time was well spent.

You probably felt pretty good about it, too. But how do we actually know when someone has learned something? Not whether they enjoyed the training or could repeat what we just told them. I mean whether they can use it three weeks later, during a crowded afternoon at the pool, when a swimmer needs a different approach, or when something unexpected requires a decision.


I've spent a lot of time in aquatic training environments, both developing staff and teaching aquatic professionals. One thing I've come to appreciate is that we can deliver a thoughtful, engaging, well-organized training and still fall short of what we intended.


That doesn't automatically mean the instructor did something wrong or the employees weren't paying attention. Sometimes we've focused so much on what we're teaching that we haven't spent enough time considering how people actually learn. Teaching something and someone learning it are not the same thing.


That's what I want to explore in Training That Transfers: how people learn, why familiar training approaches don't always produce lasting results, and what aquatic professionals can do differently. The goal isn't to make every in-service more elaborate. It's to make our limited training time more meaningful.


Engagement Doesn't Equal Effective

An engaging in-service isn't necessarily an effective one. I love a good scenario, a thoughtful discussion, or an activity that gets staff out of their chairs. But engagement and learning aren't interchangeable. We can create an activity that everyone enjoys without asking anyone to think very deeply. We can also explain a skill, demonstrate it, and have staff repeat it immediately afterward. That can be an important first step, particularly when a skill is new. But performing something while the instructor is standing nearby is different from recognizing when and how to use it independently. That's the difference I want us to pay closer attention to.


Aquatic facilities operate in environments where documentation matters. We maintain certification records, track in-service hours, document skills assessments, and demonstrate that employees have received required instruction. Those responsibilities are important. Training records support accountability, help organizations meet applicable requirements, and establish a foundation for staff development. But somewhere along the way, it's easy to start treating documentation as evidence of readiness. An employee attended the emergency action plan review, so we assume they understand their role. A lifeguard completed a scanning exercise, so we assume they'll recognize a swimmer in distress. A swim instructor participated in inclusion training, so we assume they'll adjust their teaching when a child needs a different approach. These are reasonable expectations, but they're not guarantees.


Attendance tells us someone was present. A completed activity tells us they participated. Even a successful assessment tells us something about their performance under the conditions of that assessment. None of those measures, on its own, tells us everything about how someone will perform later. That's not an argument against documentation. It's an argument for being more precise about what our documentation actually demonstrates.


Transfer of Learning

In education and cognitive psychology, transfer of learning describes our ability to use knowledge or skills learned in one situation in another. The National Research Council's How People Learn identifies transfer as a central goal of education and explains that people may remember information without being able to apply it successfully in unfamiliar circumstances. The distinction matters enormously in aquatics.


Imagine teaching lifeguards how to identify deteriorating swimmer behavior. During training, you show a video, explain the warning signs, and ask participants to identify the correct response. Everyone answers correctly. Now imagine those same lifeguards working during a crowded recreational swim. Music is playing, patrons are moving in multiple directions, and several swimmers are calling for attention. The underlying knowledge may be the same, but the circumstances are different. The lifeguard must recognize the relevant cues, distinguish them from distractions, decide what to do, and act. That is learning transfer.


The National Research Council also emphasizes that knowledge taught in only one context may be less likely to transfer flexibly to other contexts. This suggests an important training design principle: Staff need opportunities to recognize and apply the same concepts under varied, realistic conditions. A classroom explanation may be a useful beginning. It shouldn't always be the end.


Retrieval of Learning

One of the more interesting findings in learning science is that people aren't always good judges of how well they've learned something. In a 2006 study published in Psychological Science, researchers Henry Roediger and Jeffrey Karpicke compared students who repeatedly studied material with students who practiced recalling it. Repeated studying helped with immediate recall, but retrieval practice produced stronger retention on delayed tests. The researchers also found that repeated studying could increase learners' confidence in their ability to remember the material.


Think about how easily that dynamic can appear in staff training. A supervisor presents information clearly. Staff recognize the material. They've heard it before, and everything seems familiar. The session feels successful because participants are comfortable with the content. But familiarity isn't the same as independent recall, and recall isn't always the same as effective application. If we want to know whether staff can use information, we have to give them opportunities to use it without the answer sitting directly in front of them.


For example, rather than reviewing the steps of an emergency response procedure and immediately asking staff to repeat them, describe a realistic situation. Ask what they would notice first, which decision they would make, and how they would communicate with their team. Then change a detail. What if the nearest staff member is occupied? What if the patron has difficulty communicating? What if the first response doesn't work? The goal isn't to surprise staff or manufacture failure. It's to help them build the ability to recognize when and how their knowledge applies.


Aquatic professionals are responsible for much more than remembering procedures. We expect lifeguards to notice changing conditions. We expect swim instructors to adjust lessons. We expect supervisors to navigate competing priorities, respond to complaints, support employees, and make judgment calls that don't always have a perfect answer. Yet many training programs remain organized primarily around the delivery of information. Here's the policy. Here are the steps. Here's what you need to know.


Those things matter, particularly when a procedure must be followed consistently. But effective training also needs to address the decisions employees make before, during, and after applying those procedures. Consider a staff training session about inclusion. A traditional approach might explain disability terminology, review organizational expectations, and discuss the importance of accommodations. A transfer-focused approach would still provide that foundation. Then it might present a swimmer who becomes distressed when transitioning from one activity to another. What might be creating the barrier? What information would you want to gather? What could you change about the environment, communication, or lesson structure? How would you know whether your adjustment helped? Now the staff member isn't simply repeating that inclusion matters. They're practicing how to make a program more inclusive.


You're Next In-Service Training

The next time you design an in-service, begin with the end rather than the agenda. Instead of asking, "What information do I need to cover?" ask, "What should employees be able to do differently afterward?" Then consider what evidence would demonstrate that change. If the objective is better communication during emergencies, staff should practice communication. If the objective is stronger scanning, training should include meaningful observation and recognition tasks. If the objective is more inclusive instruction, instructors should practice adapting activities to different access needs. The activity should resemble the performance we hope to see.


This doesn't mean every training needs elaborate equipment, expensive simulations, or hours of preparation. Sometimes the most valuable change is replacing ten minutes of presentation with a realistic question that requires employees to think. The point is to stop treating the completion of training as the finish line. It's the beginning of a process that should continue through practice, feedback, observation, and everyday leadership.


Make It Transfer

One idea. One action. One better-trained team.


At your next in-service, choose one topic you normally teach through explanation or review. Before presenting it, write down one specific action you want staff to perform successfully on the job. Then create a short scenario that requires them to demonstrate that action or explain their decision. Don't provide the answer immediately. Give them time to think, discuss, and respond. Offer clear feedback and revisit the same skill during a future shift or training.


Ask yourself afterward: Did we simply cover the information, or did we create an opportunity to practice using it? The goal isn't to finish the training, it’s for the training to show up when it matters.




About the Author

Kate Connell, CPRP, is an aquatic leader with over 15 years of experience. In addition to her role as Senior Manager of Sales and Strategic Partnerships at HydroApps, Kate works to build safer, more inclusive aquatic environments through her business, Equitable Aquatics. You can connect with Kate at equitableaquatics@gmail.com. 



Are you interested in submitting a blog post? Reach out to Kirsten at kirsten@aquaticpros.org to share your idea and learn more about the AOAP Blog.


Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page